The morning I turned fifty-two, I stepped into a kitchen that smelled of dampness and firewood, the same kitchen in which my grandmother had cooked through many winters. She stood at the stove stirring lentils and root vegetables scented with cumin, coriander, fenugreek, and dried ginger. “Soup for Vata,” she said. Her bowl was warm, soft, moist, and satisfying, but it is more accurate to call such soup seasonally suitable food than medicine. A recipe cannot diagnose or treat constipation, anxiety, arthritis, depression, infection, or any other disorder.

Ayurveda does not state that Vata simply rises throughout late autumn and winter. In the seasonal sequence of the Charaka Samhita, Vata accumulates in summer, becomes aggravated in the rainy season, and is pacified in autumn. The winter discussion makes a different point: in a strong and healthy person, digestive power may become intense in early winter, and inadequate nourishment can disturb cold-natured Vata. Late winter is described as still colder and drier, so the early-winter regimen is continued more strongly.

Vata is classically described as dry (ruksha), light (laghu), cold (shita), rough (khara), subtle (sukshma), and mobile (chala). A freshly cooked soup can oppose several of these qualities when it is warm, moist, smooth, and moderately unctuous. This is a culinary application of Ayurvedic qualities, not proof that every cold-weather symptom is caused by Vata or that every person needs the same meal.

The Classical Winter Rationale

The Charaka Samhita advises unctuous, sour, and salty foods during early winter and mentions fats and oils, milk products, new rice, sugarcane products, and warm water. Ashtanga Hridaya likewise includes sweet, sour, and salty tastes along with wheat, black gram, milk products, fats, oils, and newly harvested grain. These passages support adequate, nourishing winter food, especially for someone with good appetite and activity. They do not establish a universal prescription to eat soup, overeat heavy food, or follow one menu regardless of constitution and digestion.

Quantity remains central. Charaka distinguishes naturally light foods such as green gram from heavier foods such as black gram and sesame and explains that proper quantity depends on digestive capacity. A person who feels hunger and digests a meal comfortably may tolerate a richer soup; someone with weak appetite, reflux, nausea, or post-meal heaviness may need a smaller portion, less fat, or a lighter preparation.

What the Warming Spices Actually Contribute

The Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India records dried ginger (Shunthi) as pungent in taste, light and unctuous in quality, hot in potency, and sweet after digestion, with actions including dipana, pachana, and Vata-Kapha pacification. Black pepper (Maricha) is pungent and bitter, light, dry, and sharp, hot in potency, and pungent after digestion; it is also recorded as Pitta-increasing. Long pepper (Pippali) is not simply “hot and dry”: the Pharmacopoeia gives it pungent taste, light and unctuous qualities, anushna virya, and a sweet post-digestive effect.

The Pharmacopoeia identifies gingerol and shogaol in dried ginger and piperine in black pepper, but the presence of constituents does not prove that a household soup raises brown-fat UCP-1, prevents winter infection, alters cytokines in a clinically meaningful way, or treats disease. No verified passage was found in Charaka prescribing Trikatu before every main winter meal. Spices here are used in modest culinary amounts for taste and traditional digestive suitability, not as a substitute for medical care.

Recipe 1: Soft Masoor Dal and Ginger Soup

Red lentil, or Masura, should not be presented as inherently Vata-pacifying. The Pharmacopoeia describes it as sweet and astringent, light and dry, cold in potency, sweet after digestion, and Vata-provoking. This recipe therefore uses thorough cooking, sufficient water, ghee, ginger, cumin, and a very small amount of asafoetida to make the final dish softer, warmer, and less dry.

Ingredients: 75 g red lentils, 650 ml water, 1 tablespoon ghee or suitable cooking oil, 1 teaspoon cumin seeds, quarter to half teaspoon dried ginger, quarter teaspoon turmeric, a small pinch of asafoetida, salt to taste, and chopped coriander if desired.

Method: Rinse the lentils and cook them until they are completely soft. Add hot water if the mixture begins to set like a paste. In a small pan, warm the ghee, add cumin and asafoetida, and cook briefly. Lower the heat, add ginger and turmeric, and immediately stir the tempering into the lentils. Simmer for three to five minutes and serve pleasantly warm.

Ayurvedic reading: The balancing feature is the preparation, not a claim that Masura itself grounds Vata. Moisture and fat oppose dryness, while warmth opposes coldness. If lentils repeatedly cause bloating, pain, or altered bowel habits, reduce the portion or choose another food rather than increasing the spices.

Recipe 2: Sweet Potato and Fresh Ginger Soup

This food-based recipe replaces the proposed ashwagandha soup. The cited PMID did not concern ashwagandha, and no reliable source was found for the claim that stirring its powder into soup after cooking preserves withanolides or guarantees bioavailability. Ashwagandha is a medicinal substance with precautions and possible interactions, so it should not be inserted into a general family recipe without individualized advice.

Ingredients: 2 medium sweet potatoes, 1 small onion, 2 cm fresh ginger, 1 tablespoon ghee or cooking oil, half teaspoon cumin, 550 ml water or unsalted vegetable stock, a small pinch of black pepper, and salt to taste.

Method: Peel and cube the sweet potatoes. Warm the ghee, gently cook the onion and ginger until soft, and add cumin. Add the sweet potatoes and liquid, cover, and simmer until completely tender. Blend until smooth, return to low heat, and adjust the consistency with hot water. Add only a small pinch of pepper.

Ayurvedic reading: No unsupported classical rasa-guna profile is assigned to sweet potato here. The usefulness of the recipe lies in its final qualities: warm, soft, moist, smooth, and moderately unctuous. People with reflux or a strong heat sensation may prefer less ginger and pepper.

Recipe 3: Masha and Cumin Winter Soup

Black gram, or Masha, has a firmer classical connection to winter food than the proposed Dashamoola bone broth. Ashtanga Hridaya includes foods prepared from black gram in the early-winter regimen, while Charaka categorizes Masha among heavier foods. It can therefore suit a substantial meal for someone with strong digestion, but it is not universally easy to digest.

Ingredients: 75 g split and skinned black gram, soaked 4 to 6 hours, 750 ml water, 1 tablespoon ghee, 1 teaspoon cumin seeds, 1 cm fresh ginger, a pinch of asafoetida, quarter teaspoon turmeric, and salt to taste.

Method: Drain and rinse the soaked dal. Cook it with fresh water until thoroughly soft; a pressure cooker may shorten the cooking time. Warm the ghee, add cumin and asafoetida, then ginger and turmeric. Stir this into the dal, simmer for five minutes, and thin with hot water until it is soup rather than a dense paste.

Ayurvedic reading: This recipe reflects the classical winter inclusion of Masha while respecting its heaviness. Begin with a modest serving and eat it at a time when appetite is clear. Persistent heaviness, belching, reflux, or lethargy after the meal suggests that the portion or recipe is not suitable for that person.

Recipe 4: Mung Soup with Ginger and Cumin

Green gram, or Mudga, is praised among pulses and is categorized as naturally light, but it is inaccurate to call it non-gas-forming or inherently Vata-pacifying. The Pharmacopoeia records sweet and astringent tastes, light and dry qualities, cold potency, sweet post-digestive effect, and Kapha- and Pitta-alleviating actions. Cooking it very soft with water and suitable fat modifies the eating experience without changing its documented classical profile.

Ingredients: 100 g split yellow mung or soaked whole green mung, 750 ml water, 1 to 2 tablespoons ghee or cooking oil, 1 teaspoon cumin seeds, 1 cm grated fresh ginger, quarter teaspoon turmeric, a small pinch of asafoetida, a pinch of black pepper, and salt.

Method: Cook the mung until very soft and beginning to break down. Add hot water as needed. Prepare a tempering with ghee, cumin, asafoetida, ginger, and turmeric. Stir it into the mung, simmer for five minutes, and finish with a small pinch of black pepper. Keep the soup moist and spoonable.

Ayurvedic reading: Mung may be preferable to Masha when a lighter pulse is wanted, but “light” does not mean suitable in unlimited quantity or guaranteed to digest without discomfort. The original claims that this soup supplies a complete amino-acid profile, clears lymph, or improves respiratory immunity were not supported by the cited PMID and have been removed.

Recipe 5: Carrot and Sesame Soup

The verified Ayurvedic foundation of this recipe is sesame, not an unsupported claim about saffron. The Pharmacopoeia records sesame as sweet, pungent, bitter, and astringent; diffusive, heavy, unctuous, and subtle; hot in potency; sweet after digestion; and Vata-alleviating. It also records Pitta- and Kapha-increasing actions, so sesame should not be described as universally balancing.

Ingredients: 4 large carrots, 1 tablespoon ghee or cooking oil, 1 tablespoon tahini or finely ground sesame seeds, 1 cm fresh ginger, half teaspoon cumin, 550 ml water or unsalted vegetable stock, salt to taste, and 4 to 5 saffron strands for aroma and colour if desired.

Method: Warm the ghee and gently cook the ginger and cumin. Add sliced carrots and the liquid, cover, and simmer until completely tender. Blend until smooth, then stir in the tahini. Add hot water if needed. Optional saffron may be steeped in a spoonful of warm water and stirred in before serving.

Ayurvedic reading: Sesame adds documented heavy, unctuous, and hot qualities to a warm, smooth soup. The optional saffron is included only as a culinary flavouring; the cited PMID did not concern saffron, and this recipe makes no claim to treat low mood, poor circulation, neurological disease, or winter depression. Anyone with sesame allergy must avoid the recipe.

Verified Ingredient Guide

The following profiles conservatively reproduce the cited Pharmacopoeia entries. The quantities are ordinary culinary starting points for approximately two servings, not therapeutic doses. Individual tolerance, recipe volume, age, medicines, and health conditions still matter.

Timing, Frequency, and Storage

No verified classical passage was found requiring these soups at lunch, before 7 p.m., or four to five days each week. Choose timing according to genuine appetite and digestive comfort. A heavier Masha soup may fit the main meal of a person with strong digestion, while a lighter mung or vegetable soup may suit another time. There is no benefit in eating a prescribed frequency when a recipe repeatedly causes discomfort.

Use ordinary food-safety rules. Refrigerate leftovers at 4°C or below within two hours of cooking, or within one hour when the surrounding temperature is above 32°C. Divide a large pot into smaller shallow containers so it cools promptly. Use refrigerated leftovers within three to four days or freeze them, and reheat leftovers to at least 74°C before allowing them to cool to a comfortable eating temperature.

Safety Disclaimer and Professional Guidance

Safety Disclaimer: These recipes are general food ideas, not treatments for arthritis, osteoporosis, infection, anxiety, depression, neurological disease, or digestive disorders. Ginger may cause abdominal discomfort, heartburn, diarrhea, or mouth and throat irritation, and herbs may interact with medicines. Fenugreek in food is different from concentrated medicinal use; NCCIH advises that amounts greater than those found in food are unsafe during pregnancy. People who are pregnant or breastfeeding, preparing food for a child, taking medicines, managing kidney, gallbladder, metabolic, gastrointestinal, or other medical conditions, or following a restricted diet should consult a qualified Ayurvedic practitioner and an appropriate healthcare provider before using medicinal herbs or making major dietary changes.

Actionable tip: Prepare a double batch of the mung soup only when it suits your digestion and schedule. Keep it moist rather than reducing it to a paste, cool and refrigerate it promptly in shallow containers, and use it within three to four days. When reheating, add a little water to restore the soft consistency and heat it thoroughly before serving.

References

1. Ayurveda-online (ayurveda-online.net)
2. Charaka Samhita — Tasyashiteeya Adhyaya
3. Easyayurveda (easyayurveda.com)
4. Charaka Samhita — Matrashiteeya Adhyaya
5. Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India
6. Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India
7. Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India
8. NCCIH
9. NCCIH
10. Foodsafety (foodsafety.gov)
11. Foodsafety (foodsafety.gov)

Emotional eating is not always the same pattern in every person. One person may eat when anxious and irregular, another when pressured and overheated, and another when heavy, sad, or unstimulated. Ayurveda approaches this pattern through ahara (food), agni (digestive capacity), manas (mind), dinacharya (daily rhythm), and the changing influence of vata, pitta, and kapha. The goal is not to shame the urge, but to read it accurately and choose a response that restores steadiness.

Contemporary physiology also describes close communication between the digestive tract and the brain. Ayurveda uses a different language, but it has long treated digestion, routine, emotion, and sensory discipline as connected parts of health. For emotional eating, this means the practical solution is rarely just “more willpower.” It is usually a combination of meal timing, food quality, dosha-appropriate substitutions, mindful eating, and support for the mind.

Prajnaparadha: The Ayurvedic Root Pattern Behind Unwise Eating

In the Charaka Samhita, prajnaparadha is described as a major cause of disease and as an error arising from disturbance of dhi (understanding), dhriti (restraint or self-control), and smriti (memory). In the context of emotional eating, this does not mean a moral failure. It describes the moment when the mind loses clear discrimination and food is used to answer an emotional signal rather than true hunger.

1. Dhi vibhramsha: impaired understanding. The person may misread anxiety, boredom, loneliness, anger, or fatigue as hunger.
2. Dhriti vibhramsha: impaired restraint. The person may recognize the urge as emotional but feel unable to pause, redirect, or choose a more balancing option.
3. Smriti vibhramsha: impaired memory. The person may forget the discomfort, heaviness, acidity, guilt, or disturbed sleep that followed a previous episode.

These three faculties give a useful map for intervention. Dhi-related patterns need awareness and education. Dhriti-related patterns need structure, routine, and fewer impulsive triggers in the environment. Smriti-related patterns benefit from food-mood journaling, mindful pauses, and repeating small corrective practices until the body remembers the better outcome.

Three Dosha-Specific Emotional Eating Patterns

The following patterns are an applied Ayurvedic framework, not a rigid diagnosis. Many people show a mixture, and the dominant pattern can change with season, stress, age, sleep, travel, and digestive strength. Use the descriptions to notice which doshic qualities appear most strongly when emotion begins to drive eating.

Vata Pattern: Anxiety-Driven Irregular Eating

Vata is classically associated with dry, light, cold, rough, subtle, and mobile qualities. When these qualities dominate the mind and digestion, emotional eating often appears as irregularity rather than steady overeating. A Vata pattern may include skipping meals, grazing while distracted, eating late at night, or reaching for dry, crunchy, quick foods when the mind feels scattered.

Common Vata-style triggers include overwork, lack of sleep, travel, excessive screen use, loneliness, fear, uncertainty, and a broken routine. The person may not sit down properly for meals, may eat while walking or multitasking, and may later experience gas, bloating, constipation, disturbed sleep, or variable appetite.

Ayurvedic support for this pattern emphasizes warmth, oiliness, steadiness, and rhythm:

• Eat at regular times, seated, without screens or hurried conversation.
• Prefer warm, cooked, moist foods such as soups, stews, khichari, cooked grains, root vegetables, and a little ghee where appropriate.
• Use sweet, sour, and salty tastes in a balanced way, because these tastes are traditionally used to pacify Vata.
• Reduce dry snacks, cold raw foods, iced drinks, excessive caffeine, and late-night grazing.
• Practice gentle Abhyanga with warm oil, especially when the body feels dry, restless, or tense.
• A qualified practitioner may consider Vata-supportive herbs such as Ashwagandha or Brahmi when appropriate for the person’s constitution, medications, and health status.

Pitta Pattern: Stress-Driven Overeating

Pitta is associated with hot, sharp, light, spreading, and liquid qualities. When Pitta drives emotional eating, the urge often follows frustration, pressure, criticism, competition, anger, perfectionism, or the feeling of losing control. The eating style may be fast, intense, and reward-oriented, especially after long periods of work or conflict.

Pitta-type cravings often move toward hot, spicy, salty, sour, fried, or strongly stimulating foods. The aftermath may include acidity, heartburn, loose stools, heat sensations, skin flare-ups, irritability, or sharp self-criticism. Because Pitta appetite can become intense quickly, skipping meals often makes this pattern worse.

Ayurvedic support for this pattern emphasizes cooling, moderation, and calm:

• Keep meals regular; avoid pushing through hunger until the body becomes reactive.
• Choose sweet, bitter, and astringent tastes in balanced meals, because these tastes are traditionally used to pacify Pitta.
• Favor cooling but digestible foods such as cooked greens, gourds, soaked raisins, ripe sweet fruits, coconut, mung dal, barley, and moderate amounts of ghee where suitable.
• Reduce very spicy, sour, salty, fried, fermented, and alcohol-containing foods when Pitta signs are active.
• Pause before meals with cooling breath practices such as Sheetali or Sheetkari if they are suitable and comfortable.
• A qualified practitioner may consider herbs such as Amalaki, Brahmi, Guduchi, or Shatavari according to the individual’s constitution, digestive state, and medical history.

Kapha Pattern: Comfort-Driven Emotional Eating

Kapha is associated with heavy, slow, cool, oily, smooth, soft, and stable qualities. When Kapha drives emotional eating, food often becomes a source of comfort, attachment, and numbness. The person may eat slowly but continue past satiety, especially when bored, sad, lonely, rejected, inactive, or emotionally stuck.

Kapha-type cravings often move toward sweet, heavy, creamy, cold, oily, or starchy foods. The aftermath may include heaviness, lethargy, sleepiness, mucus, sluggish bowels, nausea, dullness, and weight gain. This pattern is strengthened by daytime sleeping, lack of movement, cold damp weather, and repeated snacking without true hunger.

Ayurvedic support for this pattern emphasizes lightness, stimulation, and movement:

• Eat only when the previous meal is digested and true hunger is present.
• Prefer lighter, warm meals with pungent, bitter, and astringent tastes, because these tastes are traditionally used to pacify Kapha.
• Use ginger, black pepper, long pepper, cumin, coriander, turmeric, and other digestive spices according to tolerance.
• Reduce cold sweets, heavy dairy, fried foods, refined flour, excess oil, and frequent snacking.
• Use brisk morning movement, dynamic yoga, walking, or other suitable exercise to counter Kapha heaviness.
• A qualified practitioner may consider Kapha-supportive formulas such as Trikatu, Triphala, Guggulu preparations, or Punarnava where appropriate. Honey should not be heated or cooked; if used, it should be used modestly and avoided where medically unsuitable.

Diagnostic Table: Dosha Emotional Eating Patterns

This table helps identify the dominant pattern. It is normal to match more than one column, but the most useful starting point is usually the column that describes the trigger, eating style, and physical aftermath most accurately.

Mindful Eating Practices from Ayurvedic Texts

The Charaka Samhita describes eight factors of food use, called Ashta Ahara Vidhi Visheshayatana. These are especially useful for emotional eating because they shift attention from impulse to suitability: what is eaten, how it is prepared, how it is combined, how much is taken, where it comes from, when it is eaten, how it is eaten, and who is eating it.

1. Prakriti: the inherent nature of the food, such as heavy, light, dry, oily, heating, or cooling.
2. Karana: the method of preparation, because cooking, roasting, soaking, churning, fermenting, or adding fat and spices changes the food’s effect.
3. Samyoga: combination, because foods can act differently when combined than when taken alone.
4. Rashi: quantity, which should suit digestive strength, season, age, activity, and the heaviness or lightness of the meal.
5. Desha: place or habitat, including the region where the food is grown and the environment of the eater.
6. Kala: time, including season, time of day, age, and the person’s current condition.
7. Upayoga Samstha: the rules of eating, including eating with attention, at a proper pace, in a suitable place, and after the previous meal is digested.
8. Upayokta: the eater, because constitution, habit, tolerance, health condition, and emotional state determine what is suitable.

For emotional eating, Upayoga Samstha is often the first corrective doorway. Sitting down, removing screens, eating warm food, chewing properly, and stopping before heaviness can transform the same food from an unconscious emotional act into a conscious nourishing act.

The Role of Agni in Emotional Eating

Ayurveda places agni at the center of digestion, assimilation, strength, and clarity. When agni is balanced, hunger and satisfaction are easier to read. When agni is disturbed, appetite may become irregular, excessive, dull, or misleading, and emotional urges can be mistaken for digestive need.

• Vishama Agni: irregular digestion, commonly linked with Vata disturbance. Appetite fluctuates, eating becomes erratic, and bloating or gas may follow.
• Tikshna Agni: sharp or intense digestion, commonly linked with Pitta disturbance. Hunger can feel urgent, and heating foods may intensify acidity or irritability.
• Manda Agni: slow digestion, commonly linked with Kapha disturbance. Even moderate food may feel heavy, and comfort eating can deepen sluggishness.
• Sama Agni: balanced digestion. Hunger appears at appropriate times, food digests comfortably, and satisfaction is clearer.

The Ayurvedic aim is to move toward Sama Agni. Practical steps include regular meal timing, eating after the previous meal has digested, using appropriate digestive spices, choosing foods suited to the current doshic state, and avoiding repeated snacking when there is no true hunger.

The Gut-Brain Axis in Modern Language

The gut-brain axis is a modern term for bidirectional communication between the gastrointestinal tract and the central nervous system. This communication involves the enteric nervous system, vagus nerve pathways, immune signaling, endocrine signaling, and microbial metabolites. This language is different from Ayurveda, but it helps modern readers understand why digestion, stress, mood, and eating behavior often move together.

Mindful eating, meal regularity, and attention to digestive comfort are therefore not merely “diet tips.” They are practical ways to interrupt the automatic loop between emotion and food. In Ayurvedic language, they protect agni, support steadier manas, and reduce the repeated prajnaparadha cycle of knowing, forgetting, and repeating.

Herbal Support Summary by Dosha Pattern

Herbs should support the larger plan of food, routine, sleep, movement, and awareness. They should not be used as a substitute for medical care, mental health care, or treatment for an eating disorder. Consult a qualified Ayurvedic practitioner or healthcare provider before using herbs, especially if pregnant or breastfeeding, taking medication, managing diabetes, liver disease, kidney disease, hypertension, autoimmune conditions, anxiety medication use, or any chronic health condition.

• Vata pattern: focus on warm meals, routine, rest, Abhyanga, and grounding practices. Ashwagandha or Brahmi may be considered by a practitioner when suitable.
• Pitta pattern: focus on regular meals, cooling foods, reduced irritants, and calming pauses before eating. Amalaki, Brahmi, Guduchi, or Shatavari may be considered by a practitioner when suitable.
• Kapha pattern: focus on movement, lighter warm meals, digestive spices, and reducing sweet-heavy snacking. Trikatu, Triphala, Guggulu preparations, or Punarnava may be considered by a practitioner when suitable.

Building a Sustainable Practice

Ayurvedic change is most stable when introduced gradually. Emotional eating often becomes a repeated pattern over months or years, so the corrective practice should be consistent, compassionate, and realistic rather than extreme.

1. Weeks 1-2: identify the dominant dosha pattern and keep a simple food-mood journal. Note hunger level, emotion, food choice, time, and physical aftermath.
2. Weeks 3-4: establish regular meals and make one dosha-appropriate substitution for the most common craving.
3. Weeks 5-8: add one lifestyle practice: Abhyanga for Vata, cooling breath or quiet pauses for Pitta, and morning movement for Kapha.
4. Ongoing: adjust seasonally. Vata patterns often rise with travel, dryness, and irregularity; Pitta patterns often rise with heat and pressure; Kapha patterns often rise with cold, dampness, inactivity, and emotional stagnation.

Ayurveda does not treat emotional eating as a moral failure. It treats the craving as information. The food desired, the emotional trigger, the time of day, and the digestive aftermath all point toward the doshic quality that needs correction. When the pattern is understood, the response can become specific, kind, and effective.

This article is for educational purposes only. Consult a qualified Ayurvedic practitioner, nutrition professional, mental health professional, or healthcare provider before making significant dietary changes or using herbs, especially if emotional eating feels compulsive, is associated with purging, severe restriction, depression, trauma, medication use, or an existing medical condition.

References

1. Hopkinsmedicine (hopkinsmedicine.org)
2. NCCIH
3. Charaka Samhita — Katidhapurusha Sharira
4. Amrtasiddhi (amrtasiddhi.com)
5. Easyayurveda (easyayurveda.com)
6. Charaka Samhita — Rasa Vimana
7. Physiological aspects of Agni (2010), PubMed Central
8. Banyanbotanicals (banyanbotanicals.com)
9. The Gut-Brain Axis: Influence of Microbiota on Mood and Mental Health (2018), PubMed Central
10. The Enteric Nervous System and Its Emerging Role as a Therapeutic Target (2020), PubMed Central
11. Mindfulness-based interventions for obesity-related eating behaviours: a literature review (2014), PubMed Central
12. Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India
13. Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India
14. Chemical analysis reveals the botanical origin of shatavari products and confirms the absence of alkaloid asparagamine A in Asparagus racemosus (2013), PubMed
15. Therapeutic Uses of Triphala in Ayurvedic Medicine (2017), PubMed Central
16. Ijrap (ijrap.net)
17. Omicsgroup (omicsgroup.org)
18. Artofvedas (artofvedas.in)